1

When doing a bit of research into ~し sentences I've found that sometimes は/が is used and sometimes も is used, which is a bit confusing. For example,

お金もないし、時間もないし、困ったな.

お金はないし、時間はないし、困ったな.

私の部屋は狭いし暗いし家賃も高いので、早く引っ越したいです。

The first two are the same sentence with the particle changed, and the third one has 部屋 with は but 家賃 with も (why not both with も or with は)

It's all very confusing :(

Daniel
  • 1,799
  • 19
  • 31

1 Answers1

3
  1. お金もないし、時間もないし、困ったな。
  2. お金はないし、時間はないし、困ったな。

These two sentences are almost the same, but IMO the latter (using は) sounds slightly more rhythmical and exclamatory.

Sometimes は is used to list things with emphasis and emotion ("not only ~ but even also ~"). It can be used in the ~は~し~は~し construction, but it's particularly common when combined with sentence-end particle わ for exclamation:

  • 出ないわ、電気止まるわで、さんざんな目にあった。
  • 私の部屋は、狭い暗い家賃高いなので、早く引っ越したいです。

(Note that this type of わ is not feminine.)

naruto
  • 285,549
  • 12
  • 305
  • 582