I'm wondering what the reason for the mispronunciation of 円 in English came to be "yen". I can understand how some words like 東京 became "Tokyo", but "en" to "yen" seems strange. On a side note, why is this symbol 「￥」 used to denote currency? And would you pronounce that the same as 円 as well?
Asked
Active
Viewed 2.0k times
24
-
1Actually, this is a question about English rather than a question about Japanese. Also partly about the currency Japanese Yen, the area where it is used is not exactly the same as that of Japanese language (Just like the distribution of American dollar is not the same as that of English). – Jun 20 '12 at 00:36
-
1@sawa I think asking how the two symbols act (in Japanese) could pass as an acceptable question without any problems though. – atlantiza Jun 20 '12 at 00:47
-
@atlantiza That is the side note part. Not the main part. If the question is edited as to leave only that part, then it would be different. – Jun 20 '12 at 00:55
-
@Sawa: Do you think ELU would have been able to provide a better answer from people who have more knowledge about this? I asked this question here because those who are studying Japanese and speak English have probably wondered somewhat about this topic. Whereas, ELU probably wouldn't have had as strong of a grasp on the subject. – Chris Jun 20 '12 at 02:16
-
@sawa: I disagree...I don't think this is much different then asking for readings on a kanji. Also, I think this is a question a lot of beginners (and above) would have. I know I went a while (probably longer than I should have) thinking that "en" was used in some occasions, but there must be an occasion that it was read "yen" and I just hadn't learned it... – silvermaple Jun 20 '12 at 03:27
-
@Chris I do not think people on ELU are any different. People on JLU do not seem to have any more knowledge. You can see that from the fact that the answer that you accepted is only a citation from Wikipedia. They can do that as well. And questions about English is out of the scope of this site whether or not it helps Japanese learners who speak English. – Jun 20 '12 at 12:17
-
1@Sawa: However Atlantiza's second comment could not have resulted from ELU... – Chris Jun 20 '12 at 15:22
-
6@sawa: The reason is from historical Japanese, and anyway [the "yen" pronunciation is not specific to English](https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/yen), so I say it's on-topic here. – Mechanical snail Aug 23 '12 at 23:03
1 Answers
31
Why is it pronounced "yen"?
I was actually wondering this a month or so ago, but found the answer on the Wikipedia article for yen/en.
The spelling and pronunciation "yen" is standard in English. This is because mainly English speakers who visited Japan at the end of the Edo period to the early Meiji period spelled words this way. ... In the 16th century, Japanese /e/(え) and /we/(ゑ) both had been pronounced [je] and Portuguese missionaries had spelled them "ye". Some time thereafter, by the middle of the 18th century, /e/ and /we/ came to be pronounced [e] as in modern Japanese, although some regions retain the [je] pronunciation. Walter Henry Medhurst, who had not come to Japan and met any Japanese, having consulted mainly a Japanese-Dutch dictionary, spelled some "e"s as "ye" in his An English and Japanese, and Japanese and English Vocabulary (1830). In the early Meiji era, James Curtis Hepburn, following Medhurst, spelled all "e"s as "ye" in his A Japanese and English dictionary (1st ed. 1867). That was the first full-scale Japanese-English/English-Japanese dictionary, which had a strong influence on Westerners in Japan and probably prompted the spelling "yen". Hepburn revised most of "ye"s to "e" in the 3rd edition (1886) in order to mirror the contemporary pronunciation, except "yen". This was probably already fixed and has remained so ever since.
The Symbol ¥
As long as you are in Japan, ¥ is pronounced the same as 円. I'm not sure exactly why the both exist, but I'd guess that it's the same reason that we have "dollar" and "$" as well as "euro" and "€" - ¥ is not a kanji or word, but rather a symbol. Similar to these examples, even though ¥ comes before the number, you would still pronounce it at the end of the number; ¥100 and 100円 would both be pronounced ひゃくえん.
-
"Yen" is also mentioned in http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historical_kana_orthography#Romanization – Andrew Grimm Aug 31 '14 at 13:20
-
To add to the second point to atlantiza answer, note in general that currency symbols have two parallel bars crossing a letter for the main unit and a single bar crossing for the sub unit (Recently, I see only single bar with the dollar symbol, though). In case of American dollar, the main unit uses what looks like "S" today, which is not straightforward, and the sub unit uses "c", which is related to "cent". With Japanese, it is "Y", and should be clear that it comes from "yen". – Jun 20 '12 at 00:04