Questions tagged [referee]

The task of the referee is to evaluate in a timely manner a paper for publication in a specific journal or conference proceedings.

Reference: The Task of the Referee by Prof. Alan Jay Smith, University of California.

"This involves determining if the work presented is correct, if the problem studied and the results obtained are new and significant, if the quality of the presentation is satisfactory or can be made so, and what revisions and changes to the paper are necessary and/or desirable. The evaluation must be with regard to the coverage and degree of selectivity of the specific publication."

2 questions
105
votes
19 answers

How to annoy a statistical referee?

I recently asked a question regarding general principles around reviewing statistics in papers. What I would now like to ask, is what particularly irritates you when reviewing a paper, i.e. what's the best way to really annoy a statistical…
csgillespie
  • 11,849
  • 9
  • 56
  • 85
45
votes
3 answers

Reviewing statistics in papers

For some of us, refereeing papers is part of the job. When refereeing statistical methodology papers, I think advice from other subject areas is fairly useful, i.e. computer science and Maths. This question concerns reviewing more applied…
csgillespie
  • 11,849
  • 9
  • 56
  • 85