Point 1 : It's known that, usually, when the tail-index (alpha) is between 0 and 2, of a certain data set, the distribution is considered as heavy-tailed.
Point 2 : It's know that Pareto distribution is an example for heavy tailed distribution.
Let's consider Pareto distribution with alpha = 5 (say x_min = 2 for instance). Since 5 > 2, isn't point 2 become contradictory with point 1?