You can suspend and then kill the ssh process that's hung up. To do this you have to issue the escape sequence, suspend the ssh process, and then use kill -9 to kill that process.
The default escape key for the ssh that ships with OS X the ~ character. You have to enter it immediately after a new line for ssh to respect it. And then the key sequence Control-z is used to suspend and background a task in bash.
So try this key sequence:
Return
~
Control-z
If it works you'll see something like:
myhost.local:~ |ruby-2.2.0|
> ssh someremotehost
Last login: Fri Mar 6 14:15:28 2015 from myhost
someremotehost:~ |ruby-2.2.0|
> ~^Z [suspend ssh]
[1] + 48895 suspended ssh myremotehost
This line of output:
[1] + 48895 suspended ssh myremotehost
tell you the process ID of the ssh process on your machine. It's 48895 in this example. That process is still running, it's just been suspended and backgrounded. You need to kill it.
You can do that with the kill command. You want to kill it with prejudice so use the -9 option when you call kill like so:
myhost.local:~ |ruby-2.2.0|
> kill -9 48895
[1] + 48895 killed ssh someremotehost
Just use the PID of your ssh process when you call that command in place of the 48895 PID I used above.
And you'll have your prompt back.
Alternatively, you can open a second Terminal window and use ps to find the ssh process in the process list and issue the kill -9 call against the PID. Though, that kind of defeats the process of getting your prompt back in the original Terminal window, doesn't it?